I am replacing a pair of Red Wings that did their job and then some over the last decade. I just couldn't stomach the replacement price. I wore these boots for only the third time for 14+ hours straight and they were terribly comfortable! ZERO break in time. The lining is warm, more than I am used to compared to just leather, but it adds to the comfort and I assume is part of the waterproofing. The lace-to-toe seems to be a great idea too, as you can really cinch them down to nearly the end of the boot. Makes them a little less clumsy. They look very sturdy and if they continue to perform this way for the relative long haul, and hold up for 3-5 years, I will continue to be very pleased with this purchase.